mirage

Myanmar and the argument for engagement : a clash of contending moralities

DSpace/Manakin Repository

 

Search DR-NTU


Advanced Search Subject Search

Browse

My Account

Myanmar and the argument for engagement : a clash of contending moralities

Show full item record

Title: Myanmar and the argument for engagement : a clash of contending moralities
Author: Roberts, Christopher B.
Copyright year: 2006
Abstract: The domestic environment of Myanmar, in the wake of half a century of civil war and instability, has not shown any sign of any improvement. The Generals remain in control; the health and education systems are collapsing; and the people in the borderlands live under some of the worst conditions of poverty imaginable. Meanwhile, a clash of contesting moralities has emerged through a growing fissure (at least until recently) between those in favour of engagement (ASEAN) and those wanting to isolate and sanction (the West). Of these contesting moralities the most damaging has been economic isolation. Today, Myanmar receives less Official Development Assistance (ODA) per capita than any other developing country in East Asia. Laos, by contrast, is argueably little better in terms of governance yet it receives nineteens times more ODA per capita. Nevertheless, during the course of the past two decades neither engagement nor isolation has produced a tangible shift towards better governance and/or democracy. Through an analysis of the consequences of isolation and istability in Myanmar this paper argues that the international community needs to overcome its policy divide by embracing a combination of diplomatic pressure and targeted engagement designed to enhance, in the long-term, the security and stability of Myanmar and its people. Given the dire nature of the economy in Myanmar, large scale aid packages designed to alleviate the humanitarian crisis and also build the capacity of the state need to be implemented. For the purpose of capacity building and engagement, broad sweeping sanctions targeting the economy in general should be abolished while targeted sanctions (directed at the leadership) should have clear benchmarks for their removal. While the idea of even limited engagement should have clear benchmarks for their removal. While the idea of even limited engagement may be repugnant to some; the analysis will show that the 'middle path' advocated by this paper represents the best sustainable option to resolve the crisis in Myanmar.
Subject: DRNTU::Social sciences::Political science::Public administration::Asia
Type: Working Paper
Series/ Journal Title: RSIS Working Papers ; 108/06
School: S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies
Rights: Nanyang Technological University

Files in this item

Files Size Format View
RSIS-WORKPAPER_16.pdf 541.4Kb PDF View/Open

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show full item record

Statistics

Total views

All Items Views
Myanmar and the argument for engagement : a clash of contending moralities 553

Total downloads

All Bitstreams Views
RSIS-WORKPAPER_16.pdf 688

Top country downloads

Country Code Views
United States of America 203
China 175
Thailand 57
Ukraine 16
Singapore 15

Top city downloads

city Views
Mountain View 117
Beijing 96
Bangkok 30
Singapore 15
Putian 9

Downloads / month

  2014-10 2014-11 2014-12 total
RSIS-WORKPAPER_16.pdf 0 0 4 4