Palm species traits determine soil nutrient effects on seedling performance

Abstract

Environmental gradients influence plant establishment, survival, and functional traits. Along the Panama Canal Isthmus there is a strong rainfall gradient with an underlying mosaic of soil types ranging in soil nutrient availability. In this region, tree species distribution patterns are correlated with soil phosphorus availability and rainfall patterns, but how understory plant species such as palms relate to these factors is less clear. We hypothesized that due to greater resource use efficiency and optimal biomass allocation, specialist species will have greater seedling performance growing in home soil and sites compared to species not occurring there. To test this hypothesis, we used two specialist species (Chamaedorea tepejilote and Geonoma congesta) and two generalist species (Geonoma cuneata subsp. cuneata and Chamaedorea pinnatifrons), and for these four species we measured traits on seedlings and assessed their performance in shade house and field transplant experiments using five soils. Soils were sourced from five sites which varied in nutrient availability and rainfall, and were distributed along lowland tropical forests of the Panama Canal Isthmus. In the shadehouse experiment, leaf functional traits were determined by species rather than soil nutrient availability. However, in the shadehouse experiment, seedling biomass allocation, and relative growth rate were determined by interactions between species and soil, with weak support for home-site advantage for one of the species. In the field transplant experiment, seedling survival was strongly related to dry season water availability. However, species tended to have high survival at home sites and other sites with higher dry season rainfall. Together, results from these experiments suggest that understory palm species seedling performance are determined by species-specific responses to the combination of soil nutrient and water availability. This indicates that while soil nutrients influence seedling biomass allocation, dry season water availability determines both specialist and generalist seedling survival and therefore distributions along the soil nutrient and moisture gradient.